What types of firearms do you buy?

We buy most quality used firearms including handguns, rifles, and shotguns. We offer 50% of current market value for outright purchases, or 80% through our consignment program.

Do you do FFL transfers?

Yes, Amherst Armory is a licensed FFL dealer and can handle firearm transfers for online purchases. Contact us at (440) 210-7979 to arrange a transfer.

What are your store hours?

We are open Monday, Wednesday, and Thursday from 4:00 PM to 7:00 PM, and Friday from 12:00 PM to 2:00 PM. Closed Tuesday, Saturday, and Sunday.

How do I sell my guns to Amherst Armory?

You have two options: 1) Sell outright for 50% of market value with instant payment, or 2) Consign your firearm where you keep 80% of the sale price. Visit us during business hours with your firearm for an assessment.

Amherst Arms — Your Trusted FFL Dealer in Amherst, Ohio Since 2023

Q: Where is Amherst Armory located?

We are located at 1927 Cooperfoster Park Rd, Amherst, OH 44001, in the corner of the Tractor Supply Plaza, behind Arbys.

Q: Do you require background checks?

Yes, all firearm sales require a federal background check as required by law. We handle all paperwork professionally and ensure compliance with federal and Ohio state regulations.

Licensed firearms dealer specializing in quality used guns, consignment sales, and professional FFL transfers. Serving Lorain County and Northeast Ohio with integrity and expertise.

What We Do at Amherst Arms

Buy & Sell Used Firearms

We carry all kinds of used inventory. Check out our used guns section to see some of what we have available. Looking to sell? Get top dollar two ways: instant cash at 50% of current market value, or consignment at 80% of final sale price (minimum $500). We handle all paperwork, background checks on buyers, and legal compliance. Just bring your valid Ohio ID and any accessories.

New Firearms

Shop our in-store selection or browse a much larger online catalog of warehouse inventory without leaving your couch. Items tagged In-Store are on our shelves and ready to take home today. Items tagged At Warehouse aren’t in the shop yet but ship to the store in a few days with no transfer fees, no shipping charges, and no surprises. The price you see is the total price you pay. Hit the New Inventory button above to see everything available.

Transfers

Buying a firearm online from another dealer or private seller? We handle standard FFL transfers for $30 per firearm. GunBroker purchases are $35 due to their stupid $5 surcharge they bill us when selected as the receiving dealer. NFA transfers (suppressors, SBRs, machine guns) are $50 per item. Fast, professional service with all required documentation. No need to give us a heads up that something is coming. We’ll call you the moment it’s ready for pickup.

Copy of our FFL

Why Gun Owners Choose Amherst Arms

Fully Licensed FFL Dealer — Federal Firearms License holder with Class III capabilities for NFA items
Fair Market Pricing — We use real sales data from GunBroker and current market trends
Local Ohio Expertise — Based in Amherst, serving Lorain County and the greater Cleveland area

No Hidden Fees — Transparent pricing: 50% instant cash or 80% consignment
Professional Paperwork — We handle all background checks and legal documentation
Convenient Location — Easy access from I-90, located in the Tractor Supply Plaza

Visit Amherst Arms — Your Local FFL Dealer

Store Contact Info

Amherst Arms, LLC
1927 Cooperfoster Park Rd
Amherst, OH 44001

Located in the Tractor Supply Plaza, behind Arby’s

Phone: (440) 210-7979

Store Hours

Monday	4:00 – 7:00 PM
Tuesday	Closed
Wednesday	4:00 – 7:00 PM
Thursday	4:00 – 7:00 PM
Friday	12:00 – 2:00 PM 4:00 – 7:00 PM
Saturday	Closed
Sunday	Closed

Frequently Asked Questions About Amherst Arms

What is an FFL dealer?

An FFL (Federal Firearms License) dealer is licensed by the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives (ATF) to legally sell, transfer, and handle firearms. Amherst Arms is a licensed FFL dealer in Amherst, Ohio, authorized to conduct background checks and process firearm transactions.

Do I need a background check to buy a gun?

Yes. All firearm sales from Amherst Arms require a federal background check (NICS) as required by law. We handle all paperwork professionally and ensure full compliance with federal and Ohio state regulations.

What types of firearms do you sell?

We specialize in quality used firearms including handguns, rifles, and shotguns. Our inventory changes regularly based on consignments and purchases. Check our Used Inventory page for current availability.

How do I sell my gun to Amherst Arms?

Bring your firearm, valid Ohio ID, and any accessories to our store during business hours. We offer two options: 1) Instant cash at 50% of market value, or 2) Consignment where you receive 80% when the gun sells. Visit our Sell Your Guns page for details.

Do you handle FFL transfers for online gun purchases?

Yes. If you buy a firearm online from GunBroker, Armslist, or another dealer, we can handle the FFL transfer. Contact us at (440) 210-7979 with the seller’s information, and we’ll coordinate the transfer to our location in Amherst, Ohio.

Where is Amherst Arms located?

We’re located at 1927 Cooperfoster Park Rd, Amherst, OH 44001 — in the corner of the Tractor Supply Plaza, behind Arby’s. We’re easily accessible from I-90 and serve customers throughout Lorain County and Northeast Ohio.

Home